A review of recent unrest in Leicester is set to be boycotted by one part of the city's religious community.
Large-scale disorder broke out in September following tensions involving mainly young men from Muslim and Hindu communities.
On Wednesday, the review was launched by hate crime expert Dr Chris Allen.
But a group representing Hindu and Jain temples said they would not take part as they felt previous comments by Dr Allen undermined his impartiality.
The disorder gained international attention with the Indian government calling for Hindus to be better protected, while the Pakistani government said Muslims needed greater safeguards.
At the review's official launch city Mayor Sir Peter Soulsby emphasised its independent nature and said he expected conclusions by early next year.
Dr Allen said he would follow the facts and was not going to "placate anybody or any particular constituency or group".
However, objections have now been raised to the timing of the announcement and Dr Allen's appointment.
Sanjiv Patel, spokesperson for the Hindu and Jain Temples in Leicester, pointed to earlier comments on the disorder by the University of Leicester academic.
Mr Patel claimed Dr Allen's description of a march by Hindu men through a Muslim area in Leicester lacked balance and, allied with his background studying Islamophobia, made him unsuitable.
"No one is speaking about Hinduphobia here at all," he said.
"The fact he has passed judgement, the fact he has ignored, even in his comments, the other chanting that was happening in the streets of Leicester.
"Basically [he has said] there is no Islamic influence here, there is no Islamic ideology, [which] is a judgement before the facts.
"All we are asking for is a fair and independent review from parties that have no interest in the local communities from either side.
"And a process of selecting that panel or person that is clear and transparent – and none of those apply in this case."
Sir Peter was also criticised for "consistently ignoring" the feelings of the Hindu community including making the announcement during the Hindu new year.
Dr Allen said he was "surprised" at the objections given his reputation for objectivity but was keen to engage with everyone.
"For all, we will take the time to not only explain the review in more detail but also to allay any concerns they might have in terms of their participation.
"Given the concerns expressed by the city's Hindu temple and community centre leaders, we would like to expedite this opportunity to ensure they – and the city's Hindus more widely – feel confident in being able to support and contribute to the review process," he said.
A city council spokesperson said: "We have every confidence in the independence, impartiality and expertise of the University of Leicester and Dr Chris Allen and his team, and we look forward to receiving the report when it is complete."
Yasmin Surti, secretary of the Leicestershire Federation of Muslim Organisations, said it be "folly" to give up on the process before meeting Dr Allen.
"We take this opportunity to ask our colleagues, neighbours, and friends in the Hindu community to at least meet with Professor Allen with a view to being open minded and accepting the review and subsequent recommendations in order that we can move forward collectively," she said.
Follow BBC East Midlands on Facebook, on Twitter, or on Instagram. Send your story ideas to eastmidsnews@bbc.co.uk.
Leicester disorder independent review announced
Further arrests following unrest in Leicester
King meets police boss over Leicester disorder
University of Leicester
Leicester City Council
Leicestershire Police
Collection of Jack Daniel’s Tennessee Whiskey sells for more than £6,000 at Harborough auction
Tickets on sale for Melton youth talent show
Campaigners gather outside quarry gates in protest against plans near Lutterworth
Huge crowds enjoy spooktacular night in the Play Close
Explosions over Kyiv as Russia attacks Ukraine infrastructure
'It's our fault they died': Seoul grieves its young
Shanghai Disney visitors trapped after lockdown
The museum that regenerated a Spanish city
How the Seoul Halloween tragedy unfolded
Eyewitness: 'I was trying to do CPR, but they were both dead'
Are 15-minute cities the future? Video
The UK terror survivors tracked down by conspiracists
Why five states have slavery on the ballot in 2022
Syrup medicine deaths devastate Indonesia
Inside US military cyber team’s defence of Ukraine
How Brazil's election campaign turned ugly
The millennials in sexless marriages
Why a 90s cult novel still appeals now
How maths unlocked a casino loophole
© 2022 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read about our approach to external linking.
